VR Comparison: Simula One vs. Valve Index vs. Quest 2

Time 4 minute read Calendar 2021-12-26 Person George Singer Pricetags #update

Simula has recently uploaded its headset specs onto vr-compare.com, a helpful site which shows VR comparisons in a standardized format. Below is a comparison of the Valve Index (the best headset officially supported by Simula's window manager), the Oculus Quest 2 (most popular portable VR headset), and the upcoming Simula One. We have bolded the metrics which we consider particularly important.

The usual disclaimer: Since we are still actively developing the Simula One, some of these its specs might change over time.

Valve IndexOculus Quest 2Simula One
ManufacturerValveOculusSimulaVR
Websitevalvesoftware.comoculus.comsimulavr.com
Device TypePC-powered VRStandalone VRStandalone VR
Platform
SteamVROculus Home, SteamVR (Facebook account required)Linux
AnnouncedApril 29, 2019September 15, 2020December 14, 2021
Release DateApril 30, 2019October 12, 2020Unreleased (expected January 2022 Kickstarter)
Retail Price$499 (headset only); $749 (with controllers); $999 (with controllers, base stations)$299 (with controllers); 128 GB model: $299; 256 GB: $399TBD
Purpose of HeadsetGaming/Entertainment DeviceGaming/Entertainment DeviceVR Computer (VRC)
OpticsDual-element canted Fresnel lensesFresnel lensesTriple-element non-fresnel design
Display Type2 x LCDSingle Fast switch LCD2 x LCD
Subpixel LayoutRGB stripeRGB stripeRGB stripe
Resolution1440x1600 per eye1832x1920 per eye2448x2448 per eye
PPD11.0720.5835.5 [1]
Refresh Rate144 Hz120 Hz90 hz
Field of View107° horizontal; 104° vertical89° horizontal; 93° vertical100°
PassthroughDual 960x960 passthrough camerasGrayscale via tracking camerasDual wide-angle high-resolution RGB cameras
IPD Range58-70 mm hardware adjustable58-68 mm (hardware adjustable); 3 fixed IPD settings: 58mm, 63mm, 68mm55mm-77mm hardware adjustable
DimensionsN/A191.5 x 102 x 142.5 mm (excluding headstrap)TBD
Weight809 g (with headstrap)503 g (with headstrap)TBD
MaterialPlastic, foam facial interfacePlastic, foam facial interfacePlastic, foam facial interface
HeadstrapHard retractable padded strap, detachable speakersFlexible fabric strapHard padded retractable strap
ColorsBlackWhiteBlack / White / Orange
Tracking Type6 DoF Inside-out (marker based)6 DoF Inside-out via 4 integrated cameras6 DoF Inside-Out, TBD
Base Stations2 x SteamVR 2.0
Eye TrackingTBD
Face Tracking
Hand TrackingTBD
Body Tracking
SpeakersOff ear stereo speakersIntegrated stereo speakers
Microphone
3.5mm Audio Jack
PortsFront USB portUSB-C1 USB4/Thunderbolt 4; 3-4 USB3.2 Gen 2 via USB-C with DisplayPort alt mode
Video ConnectionDisplayPort 1.2, USB 3.0Oculus Link via USB-C (Wireless via Virtual Desktop, AirLink)DisplayPort 1.4a, USB 3
WiFiWiFi 6Wi-Fi 6
BluetoothBluetooth 5.0 LEIntegrated
ChipsetN/AQualcomm Snapdragon XR2Integrated
CPUN/AOcta-core Kryo 585 (1 x 2.84 GHz, 3 x 2.42 GHz, 4 x 1.8 GHz)i7-1165G7 Processor (4.70 GHz / 12M cache)
GPUN/AAdreno 650Integrated (Iris Xe graphics)
MemoryN/A6 GB16 GB (dual-channel)
StorageN/A128 GB (256 GB also available, 64 GB model discontinued)1TB NVMe M.2 SSD
SD Card SlotN/ATBD
Battery CapacityN/A3640 mAhTBD
Battery LifeN/A3 hoursTBD
Charge TimeN/A2.5 hoursTBD

[1] Our headset PPD has recently dropped from 36.2 (last week) to 35.5. Last week we had to make a tough optics decision to trade off a slight amount of PPD for "pupil swim" correction.